• About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Awards
  • Classifieds
  • Login
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Membership
Quota Media
Omnibuzz

Food systems news

Wednesday July 6 2022

Great minds think aloud

  • News
    • All
    • In the news
    • Features
    • Opinion
    Mr Justice Linden: “If it contains excess fat, sugar or salt, that product is adverse to a child's health"

    Kellogg’s loses court case over sugary cereal

    Farmer Andy Pimbley examining ripening strawberries inside a polytunnel at Claremont Farm in Bebington on the Wirral © Colin McPherson/FT

    Labour shortfall leading to ‘catastrophic’ food waste

    The Longview Power Plant, a coal-fired plant, stands on August 21, 2018 in Maidsville, West Virginia. The plant’s single unit generates 700 net megawatts of electricity from run-of-mine coal and natural gas. Spencer Platt | Getty Images

    US Supreme Court limits EPA authority

    “Understanding the emergence of CC398 in European livestock is vitally important for managing the risk it poses to public health”

    Super bug that arose in pigs can jump to humans

    Martin Lines, UK chair for the Nature Friendly Farming Network, says farmers will continue moving away from fertilisers and pesticides

    Fertilisers: going cold turkey in a time of crisis

    European Commission Vice-President Frans Timmermans, European Commissioner for Health and Food Safety Stella Kyriakides, and European Commissioner for the Environment Virginijus Sinkevicius

    EU to halve use of pesticides, heal nature

    trade deals

    WTO strikes global trade deals after ‘roller coaster’ talks

    inflation

    Food inflation is swallowing Latin America’s dietary staples

    Protestors outside UK Parliament with a placard reading, "Keep the protocol, keep the peace."

    New EU legal action over post-Brexit deal changes

    Buyers at Risk Countries in Africa and Asia are among the most reliant on Ukraine grain

    US quietly urges Russia fertiliser deals

  • Business
  • Policy
  • Research
  • Sections
    • All
    • Retail
    • Data
    • Society
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Food Safety
    • Governance
    • Security
    • Sustainability
    • Agriculture
    • Rights
    • Tech
    Mr Justice Linden: “If it contains excess fat, sugar or salt, that product is adverse to a child's health"

    Kellogg’s loses court case over sugary cereal

    Farmer Andy Pimbley examining ripening strawberries inside a polytunnel at Claremont Farm in Bebington on the Wirral © Colin McPherson/FT

    Labour shortfall leading to ‘catastrophic’ food waste

    The Longview Power Plant, a coal-fired plant, stands on August 21, 2018 in Maidsville, West Virginia. The plant’s single unit generates 700 net megawatts of electricity from run-of-mine coal and natural gas. Spencer Platt | Getty Images

    US Supreme Court limits EPA authority

    “If we lose territory we lose everything. It’s that simple.” Pic: Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador

    Ecuador’s Indigenous peoples: we are protecting our territories

    “Understanding the emergence of CC398 in European livestock is vitally important for managing the risk it poses to public health”

    Super bug that arose in pigs can jump to humans

    Martin Lines, UK chair for the Nature Friendly Farming Network, says farmers will continue moving away from fertilisers and pesticides

    Fertilisers: going cold turkey in a time of crisis

    European Commission Vice-President Frans Timmermans, European Commissioner for Health and Food Safety Stella Kyriakides, and European Commissioner for the Environment Virginijus Sinkevicius

    EU to halve use of pesticides, heal nature

    Executive director of Nourish Scotland, Pete Ritchie: “If the UK could just get over itself, alignment on sustainable food with the EU would be helpful”

    Scottish food bill: a dram to celebrate the end of the beginning

    trade deals

    WTO strikes global trade deals after ‘roller coaster’ talks

    Trending Tags

    • Covid-19
    • UK
    • Retail
  • Comms unit
  • Shop
  • Events
  • News
    • All
    • In the news
    • Features
    • Opinion
    Mr Justice Linden: “If it contains excess fat, sugar or salt, that product is adverse to a child's health"

    Kellogg’s loses court case over sugary cereal

    Farmer Andy Pimbley examining ripening strawberries inside a polytunnel at Claremont Farm in Bebington on the Wirral © Colin McPherson/FT

    Labour shortfall leading to ‘catastrophic’ food waste

    The Longview Power Plant, a coal-fired plant, stands on August 21, 2018 in Maidsville, West Virginia. The plant’s single unit generates 700 net megawatts of electricity from run-of-mine coal and natural gas. Spencer Platt | Getty Images

    US Supreme Court limits EPA authority

    “Understanding the emergence of CC398 in European livestock is vitally important for managing the risk it poses to public health”

    Super bug that arose in pigs can jump to humans

    Martin Lines, UK chair for the Nature Friendly Farming Network, says farmers will continue moving away from fertilisers and pesticides

    Fertilisers: going cold turkey in a time of crisis

    European Commission Vice-President Frans Timmermans, European Commissioner for Health and Food Safety Stella Kyriakides, and European Commissioner for the Environment Virginijus Sinkevicius

    EU to halve use of pesticides, heal nature

    trade deals

    WTO strikes global trade deals after ‘roller coaster’ talks

    inflation

    Food inflation is swallowing Latin America’s dietary staples

    Protestors outside UK Parliament with a placard reading, "Keep the protocol, keep the peace."

    New EU legal action over post-Brexit deal changes

    Buyers at Risk Countries in Africa and Asia are among the most reliant on Ukraine grain

    US quietly urges Russia fertiliser deals

  • Business
  • Policy
  • Research
  • Sections
    • All
    • Retail
    • Data
    • Society
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Food Safety
    • Governance
    • Security
    • Sustainability
    • Agriculture
    • Rights
    • Tech
    Mr Justice Linden: “If it contains excess fat, sugar or salt, that product is adverse to a child's health"

    Kellogg’s loses court case over sugary cereal

    Farmer Andy Pimbley examining ripening strawberries inside a polytunnel at Claremont Farm in Bebington on the Wirral © Colin McPherson/FT

    Labour shortfall leading to ‘catastrophic’ food waste

    The Longview Power Plant, a coal-fired plant, stands on August 21, 2018 in Maidsville, West Virginia. The plant’s single unit generates 700 net megawatts of electricity from run-of-mine coal and natural gas. Spencer Platt | Getty Images

    US Supreme Court limits EPA authority

    “If we lose territory we lose everything. It’s that simple.” Pic: Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador

    Ecuador’s Indigenous peoples: we are protecting our territories

    “Understanding the emergence of CC398 in European livestock is vitally important for managing the risk it poses to public health”

    Super bug that arose in pigs can jump to humans

    Martin Lines, UK chair for the Nature Friendly Farming Network, says farmers will continue moving away from fertilisers and pesticides

    Fertilisers: going cold turkey in a time of crisis

    European Commission Vice-President Frans Timmermans, European Commissioner for Health and Food Safety Stella Kyriakides, and European Commissioner for the Environment Virginijus Sinkevicius

    EU to halve use of pesticides, heal nature

    Executive director of Nourish Scotland, Pete Ritchie: “If the UK could just get over itself, alignment on sustainable food with the EU would be helpful”

    Scottish food bill: a dram to celebrate the end of the beginning

    trade deals

    WTO strikes global trade deals after ‘roller coaster’ talks

    Trending Tags

    • Covid-19
    • UK
    • Retail
  • Comms unit
  • Shop
  • Events
No Result
View All Result
Quota Media
No Result
View All Result
Home Topics Security

Deadly food systems: poverty, Covid-19 and the Irish Famine

Parallels with the devastating British food system that killed at least one million

by Martin McNamara
June 11, 2020
in Features, Governance
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
Just as in the Irish Famine, poverty is Covid's most deadly weapon

The eviction of Thomas Considine at Moyasta, County Clare. IMAGE: NATIONAL LIBRARY OF IRELAND.

200
SHARES
2.2k
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Facebook

On the face of it, the Covid-19 pandemic has little in common with the Potato Famine that devastated the Irish population in the 1840s.

One involved a disease that attacked the leaves and tuber of the potato plant, and that somehow led to the decimation of the people of a small island clinging to the western edge of Europe.

The other is a virus that affects lungs and airways, has so far killed tens of thousands of people globally, with the final death toll likely to be much, much higher, and wrought havoc with the world’s economies.

However, there are some parallels that we can draw between these two seismic events.

The potato blight of the mid-19th century is remembered in the history books as a uniquely Irish tragedy, but the blight itself, like Covid-19, was actually a global phenomenon.

The potato, brought to Europe from the New World of the Americas, was found to be a hardy, versatile vegetable that could be produced in pretty much any climate and quickly became a staple crop across northern Europe.

So when the blight, which had already wrecked crops in Mexico and the United States, arrived in Europe, it devastated the potato yield across the continent.

Just as Irish tenant farmers were waking up to find the potato tubers rotting in the ground, farmers in Belgium, Holland and France were facing the same scenes.

Different food systems meant the blight did not devastate Belgium, Holland and France

So then why did the blight cause such devastation to Ireland; and why was that devastation not in the history of these other nations?

The answer speaks to two of the aspects of the Covid-19 crisis that we have all been watching unfold these past months. The first is poverty.

Imposing poverty

In the 18th century much of Ireland was owned by an aristocracy of English and Anglo-Irish landlords, many of whom were absent and while their families had held on to these vast estates for centuries.

Much of these great estates were rented out in small parcals of land to the indigenous Irish population; a single field might have strips of land allotted to many Irish families, all toiling to eke out a subsistence living.

It was an economical model that worked for no one. The poor Irish struggled to survive the year, looking to yield enough of a crop that would feed their family, pay their rent to the landlord’s agent and allow them enough to trade or pay for a few essentials like a small amount of meat and other vegetables.

The poorest are dying of Covid-19 at twice the rate of the richest

For their Anglo-Irish overlords, this low level, subsistence farming was a highly ineffective for the delivery of income or in terms of developing a more efficient, sustainable estate.

As a crop, the potato was well suited to Ireland’s cold, wet, changeable climate and damp soil.

And, fatally, a farmer could produce two crops of potato in a single year.  Because of this, these poor Irish pheasants became almost wholly dependent on the potato for their subsistence survival; a terrible situation to be in when the blight hit.

Those farmers in other countries suffered hardship when their potato crop failed, but they had other crops and livestock to keep them going.

No one knows exactly how many Irish died in the famine. One million is a conservative estimate; too many to get proper burials, or to be accurately counted.

The Government sought to protect the free market over human lives

The blight on the potato did not kill them; it was starvation and the accompanying diseases like typhus that did the job.

Poverty killed them.

And while the media and politicians of today talk about the Covid-19 pandemic as being the great leveller, affecting all of us equally, the reality is starker.

Research from the Office of National Statistics found that people living in the poorest parts of England and Wales are dying of the virus at twice the rate of those in the richest areas.

How governments respond

The second lesson of the Famine for us, this Covid-19 generation, is about the importance of how governments respond to a major crisis

During the potato blight, other crops grown in Ireland were unaffected.

And, while Irish peasants starved along the back roads or died in ditches, the town’s shops had an overabundance of produce for sale and exports of foods, including livestock, butter, peas and beans, actually increased during the famine years.

The government imported inadequate supplies of cheap maize from America while still allowing food to be exported. They provided a bare minimum of support, from soup kitchens and poor houses for the most destitute to public works programmes, and on the whole insisting that the landlords should bear the greater responsibility for their tenants.

However, many of the absent landlords had been in debt before the blight. Now they had lost the small income they received from their tenant farmers. Many turfed the farmers and families out of their homes and pulled in the roofs to stop them returning, perhaps seeing the famine as an opportunity to develop their land into larger, more profitable holdings. The National Library of Ireland has a startling photographic record of these evictions.

The British government’s attitude to the Irish famine is still a cause for debate.

Most historians would agree that the worst outcomes of the famine could have been avoided if the government had the political will to prevent them.

Arguments continue about whether that behaviour was borne out of ignorance, incompetence or inertia. Or it was developed from malice, fed by anti-Irish and anti-Catholic sentiment.

Some historians maintain it was a deliberate policy of laissez faire; that it was more important for the Government of the day to protect the free market economy than save human lives.

Whatever the reasons, their collective inaction and inadequate response made a major contribution to the death toll.

Sign up for Best of Quota
  Thank you for Signing Up
Please correct the marked field(s) below.
1,true,6,Contact Email,2 1,false,1,First Name,2 1,false,1,Last Name,2
Tags: Covid-19United KingdomFamineIreland
Previous Post

What really matters – food itself and community

Next Post

You tell us: innovating in lockdown

Martin McNamara

Martin McNamara

Martin McNamara is a London-based national news journalist, Radio 4 broadcaster, author and playwright. He's a board member of the Irish Film Festival London. Martin's award-winning dramas have been performed across London and at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival. Martin McNamara's books include Your Ever Loving.

Next Post
atthew Cushen is a London-based investor, strategist and consultant in food retail, via his dual businesses Worth Capital and Uprising Consulting.

You tell us: innovating in lockdown

Please login to join discussion

Editor's Picks

“If we lose territory we lose everything. It’s that simple.” Pic: Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador
Rights

Ecuador’s Indigenous peoples: we are protecting our territories

by May Davies
July 1, 2022
0
1.1k

Indigenous protestors in Ecuador remain wary, despite the agreement which has ended 18 days of strikes in which at least...

Read more
"At SCOOP we don’t demand exclusivity and actively encourage farmers to find new and better markets for themselves." Pic: Cotswolds farmer by David George

Paying farmers 75p for each £1 consumers spend on their produce

May 23, 2022
2k
Signing ceremony of PAGES, in Brazil’s state with the highest poverty and food insecurity rates. Pic: IFAD/Tayna Abreu

Food security meets Amazon protection in new UN project

May 20, 2022
1.7k
Man holding his chin facing laptop

Companies urge convergence on climate reporting standards

May 20, 2022
1.6k
"People need time at point of sale to learn to eat in a way that protects the planet"

Shifting to care – the benefits of being the most inconvenient supermarket

May 2, 2022
1.4k
Twitter Youtube LinkedIn
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Awards
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • Classifieds
  • Events
  • Login

Popular Tags

Covid-19 United States United Kingdom Brexit United Nations 2021 Food Systems Summit European Union China Food and Agriculture Organization Food banks Meat Climate Change COP26 World Food Programme UK Nestle Food waste Farmers

Best of Quota

Our audience's free secret weapon, leaving others to ask, "What do they know, that I don't?"


Thank you for Signing Up
Please correct the marked field(s) below.
1,true,6,Contact Email,21,false,1,First Name,21,false,1,Last Name,2

© 2021 Quota Media Limited | All rights reserved | Registered Company Number 12581018      Online Web Fonts

Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Ethical Policy      Cookie Policy     

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Policy
  • Research
  • Comms unit
  • Shop
  • Events
  • Membership subs
  • Awards
  • Contact
  • About

© 2021 Quota Media Limited | All rights reserved | Registered Company Number 12581018      Online Web Fonts

Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Ethical Policy      Cookie Policy     

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In